Saturday, 5 April 2008

India Whipped !

Click this icon for all India vs South Africa 2008 articles @ TCWJ India vs South Africa: Day Three, Second Test at Ahmedabad


Scorecard




If you were a compulsive India cricket fan, prone to clutching at straws, you might have woken up to day three of this test mismatch at Ahmedabad with a simple prayer on your lips, which might have gone something like this -

Our Father in heaven,
hallowed be your name,
your kingdom come,
your will be done,
on earth as in heaven.
Give Smith today an ounce of greed.
Forgive us our score
as we forgive those who score against us.
Save us from the trial of time
and deliver us from evil.

The key line of your prayer might have been "Give Smith today an ounce of greed," hoping that he, Gareme Smith, may be swayed from common sense and yesterday's brief shower, and be tempted to allow AB de Villiers to bat on a while to add to his jingling pouch of runs. In a charitable vein you might have prayed AB would go beyond emulating Sehwag in this series. You might have perhaps fervently promised to open the bowling with Jaffer and Dravid to allow him that comfort....

Not that it was needed, for the regular bowlers did a fair job of being hospitable with their own flair and enthusiasm. But one of the straws you clutched at might have been that Smith would use up at least two sessions of the nine he could easily burden you with.

Of course, somewhere in the back of your mind, based upon the body language of the Indian players, you perhaps knew that a session or two were more than enough and Smith was unlikely to bat another seven sessions to oblige you. But you were clutching at straws and the prayer was undermined by the motive beneath it. Smithy did what every lay cricket player with an ounce of commonsense might have done - he declared first thing in the morning and left the Indian team without a place to hide and the fans without any more prayers to send up or straws to clutch at.

Veeru began well and left as if suddenly unwell. Then the pitch which was dead as a dodo for 141.2 overs of the South African innings sprang to life as if by oriental magic.

Dravid fended into the slips, Jaffer did something he usually does in such conditions, and was soon easing his hard-working tired self in the dressing room, and Laxman forgot he was in a cricket match for the second time in this test match.

This was karma catching up....India penalized for every bit of casualness they came into this series with. For every bit of thought poverty that infects them like a ticking time-bomb. For every bit of hangover from the past they were still hanging on to.

It was time for some batting practice hereon...a long session of nets to prepare for the next match. Saurav had his stint and left when he felt he had found the right touch.

Dhoni pretended he was batting out three days, but one knew better...Some say, he ensured himself another test match and perhaps ten test series with that 132-ball effort.

At the time of writing this blog, India isn't lasting three sessions, they have played this match in a fog, and it showed starkly as if in bright sunshine.

One will try and understand if the Indian thinktank had any sort of plan for this game at any stage. Lest some one feels one is being too harsh with the wonderful Indian cricket team, and to be fair to them and their strategists, one will have to pore over the replays over the next few days to pick out a speck of the supposed gameplan.

As far as I can see, they came in to this match ( and series ) with plenty of masochistic selections and attitudes...they craved a whipping and they got it nice and proper.

Well done South Africa, for you have drawn the blinds, sunlight streams in. It's quite another matter that the men huddled inside are quite blind to it.


Soon we will have the stats...how often has India been thrashed inside three days at home, and the like? One worries the fall-out of this will be to rush in the likes of Yuvrajs and Rohits rather than the correct men, or worse, do nothing at all.

12 comments:

Soulberry said...

Lax? Jaffer?Dhoni?

Dravid has looked out of focus for a while now.

Victoria-Minerva said...

"One worries the fall-out of this will be to rush in the likes of Yuvrajs and Rohits". My fear exactly. I'm pretty sure that is on Dhoni's mind.

arjwiz said...

At least Sachin wasn't playing this game or his head would have been called for too.

Or is it being called for, nonetheless?

LBW said...

May be we are the only team whose players look invincible the last night. Wake up, they look axeable too, if there is such a word.

I think Laxman must go, one reason being his inability to contribute to wins, the 2nd is not able to guard the tail!

Watching Rahul Dravid has been painful, Ganguly just survived another day. In the above list of to-be-retired cricketers, there is no Ganguly only because he scored 87? 87 in 6 innings? Good enough?

Say goodbye to Jaffer! Whom are you fooling, Mr. Vengsarkar? The 1st thing Vengsarkar did, as soon as he became CEO of the selection committee - install Jaffer in both tests and ODIs. I think I had a discussion with Soulberry on this long long time before elsewhere, I said Jaffer is here to stay. Luckily for us, Jaffer scored 4 ducks in 5 matches in ODIs; Even if Jaffer scored a 40 in one match, for the next 10 - 15 matches Jaffer would have been continued!

Ottayan said...

I mentioned Dravid because he seems to have made up his mind.

Jaffer is an enigma whereas Dhoni should be persisted with.

Straightdrive said...

Rahul is a big worry for India. As SB put it he seems to be out of focus for quite some time now. The pressure is on him now to perform or leave. This series could well turn out to be his last if he fails in the next test.

LBW you are bit harsh on Laxman here. Yes he didn't perform much in this series but in Aus he was the one who set the balls rolling and doing so with little or no discomfort. I however agree with you on Ganguly. Both Ganguly and Dravid must make up their minds. Do they have it in them to deliver anymore? If yes then show it in the middle else hang your boots. It is better to leave with your head still high than being axed. This applies to Dravid in particular. I am a big supporter of Dravid it seems he is trying just clinging on to it. He is not at ease with his approach or his batting.

mikesiva said...

Could the sun be setting on the Fantastic Four? SOoner or later, your powers start to wane....

But to me some big mistakes were made. Winning the toss, it's foolhardy to choose to bat first on a greentop against the best pace attack in the world. It is also silly of the groundsmen to plrepare a pitch to suit the visitors.

Finally, selection....

Replacing Tendulkar with Pathan was madness! Dhoni is not a number six. Sachin should've been replaced by a batsman on this pitch, maybe Yuvraj. If Pathan was to come in, it would be at the expense of a bowler.

Obaid said...

hmm, interesting discussion. I havent been watching much live cricket recently, but it seems that Dravid has never been the same since he was "rested" and since the captaincy switch in Tests. Do other people feel the same?

Also is there likely to be a domino effect, i.e if one of the fab 4 is under performing or unfit consistently (read Tendulkar) then does it lead to pressure on the rest? I would think so...

Soulberry said...

Victoria, Dhoni could well be the cpatian for the third test. he would have been for the second too if Kumble hadn't decided to push himself.

While I may be ambivalent about Dhoni the test player, and certain about his preferences and direction of Indian cricket just as you are, I also feel that quality of his along with a healthy dose of the ability to make a demand and stand by it till either it is fulfilled or the point is made, may just be the required stuff if Jaffer has to go.

There is no other way...no other force...that can disturb the calm and serene Jaffer in the midst of his ruins as LBW puts it.

The day isn't far off when at least three out of the four have to leave...I'm inclined to agree with Ottayan that Dravid appears to be in that phase when one is clearly making up one's mind. His body language suggests so, and I'd give him the time to make it up...even if he asks for a sabbatical or a vacation to do so. He, out of all four, is the one player I would like to have back in peak form and state of mind for test matches, for his fitness is also the best.

Obaid, it is observable that since he relinquished the captaincy, in whatever circumstances, and which we do not know the details of, Rahul hasn't been the same. You can see he is wandering...a bit like a man suddenly freed of a burden. The way his resignation as captain came about, I wouldn't be surprised if he announced retirement as suddenly. India cannot afford to lose him at this stage...out of all four, he is the one who can ensure some smoothness during the inevitable transition. At least that's what his legacy suggests.

Arjwiz, no man, I wasn't calling for any head other than Jaffer's. Yeah...Dhoni too perhaps yes for I find him not fitting the way he should in the test team. Limited overs...he's brilliant.

His contribution at 6-7 is not what he is tipped into the team for, and he doesn't bring the useful options which a beleagured bowling attack sorely needs without sacrificing the 20-30 runs he is likely to score. DK can do that job perfectly well in test matches and perhaps better.

I agree Mikey, a pure batsman should have been replaced with a pure batsman. If you recall I mentioned elsewhere that Tendulkar should have been replaced by either Chopra or any of the other batsmen you'd like.

Pathan could have come in place of Jaffer.

The fact that Jaffer is persisted with, especially in these circumstances where Tendulkar was out injured, makes me ask the question - when was the last time there wasn't a single Mumbaiyya in the Indian playing eleven? The answer to that will suggest why he continues to play in the team calmly, serenely, stylishly, well-mannerdly and ineffectively.

Naked Cricket said...

soulberry,
I'd like to stay with your comment on Dravid - believe he's in a situation not entirely of his own making. More than a li'l nudge from the powers that be. Don't think he is wanted around either, and it shows - either that, or RD has some serious demons to fight.

The one-day exclusion was a strong pointer. In spite of his slump, he's scrapped and still influenced tests.

Trouble is, the expectations of RD are much higher than say, a Ganguly. We expected him to score big at Ahmedbad. We didn't expect Ganguly to. Ganguly though, doesn't scrap. He plays pretty. Even the 40s and 50s are good looking. But do they influence games?

Right now, it's down to Dravid's entire test career vs Ganguly's last year of rediscovery as a test batsman.

One must outweigh the other for Indian cricket to find its balance.

scorpicity said...

Yes Dravid definitely seems different in the middle... he is perfectly alright in the domestic matches somehow he seems to be playing to cautiously with thoo many thoughts in his mind.

On the brighter side, we got to watch some good fast bowling from the South Africans.